Alice Brock Leaves Lasting Legacy As Inspiration For Alice’s Restaurant
Thanksgiving takes on special meaning when remembering the life of Alice Brock, the woman who inspired Arlo Guthrie’s iconic song “Alice’s Restaurant Massacree.” Alice passed away on November 20, 2024, at the age of 83, just days before America celebrated this beloved holiday. Her passing resonates deeply within the community and among fans of Guthrie’s poignant story wrapped around humor and social critique.
Arlo Guthrie took to social media to honor his long-time friend, sharing how significant Alice was to his life and career. He reminisced about their first meeting back in 1962 when she served as the school librarian at The Stockbridge School, where Guthrie and his friends found solace and community. “Alice passed away one week before Thanksgiving. She was living in one of her favorite places—Provincetown, Massachusetts, where she’d been for over four decades,” he posted on his Rising Son Records Facebook page. “Alice and my daughter, Annie, had spoken together recently, and during our last phone call, we laughed together, knowing it was likely our last chance to chat.”
Alice Brock’s life was anything but ordinary. She was not just the owner of the famous restaurant, The Back Room, which later became known as Alice’s Restaurant; she was also an artist, author, and most famously, the living embodiment of the earthy spirit captured by Guthrie’s song. The restaurant was situated within the repurposed walls of an old church, where Alice cultivated an environment of camaraderie and artistic exploration, becoming embedded within the cultural milieu of the 1960s Berkshires.
It all started at Thanksgiving 1965 when Guthrie and his friend, Rick Robbins, visited Alice, preparing to partake in the usual holiday spirit. After the dinner, they encountered the comically absurd predicament of discarding their trash. With the city dump closed for the holiday, the pair made the fateful decision to add their refuse to an existing heap on the side of the road. This simple act of rebellion, intertwined with pampered hospitality, spiraled them directly to jail.
Guthrie’s committed storytelling style became famous through the song, which is now played on radio stations each Thanksgiving. The tale includes details of their arrest and the resulting fine for illegal dumping, highlighting the bewildering bureaucracy present at the time — all of which humorously ties back to the Vietnam War draft, giving the song much of its anti-establishment flavor. “You can get anything you want at Alice’s Restaurant” became the refrain, heralding the whimsical notion of communal living and transcending festival folklore.
Although Alice Brock became synonymous with the song, she often expressed mixed feelings about her role as the muse for Guthrie’s work. During interviews, she articulated her feelings about being packaged as ‘Alice of Alice’s Restaurant.’ Even as the song expanded her fame, she stated she often felt trapped within the bounds of the character it portrayed. “So not true,” she said about the portrayal of her life and times.
Attaining commercial success with her restaurants, including follow-ups like Take-Out Alice and Alice’s at Avaloch, her cooking and culinary expertise were well-celebrated. Yet, her early forays were more than just potato salad and turkey dinners. Alice authored “The Alice’s Restaurant Cookbook,” where she combined humor and tasty recipes, providing readers glimpses of her artistic spirit, even inserting whimsical illustrations throughout. Despite the trials of running a restaurant, she managed to maintain her unique voice against the backdrop of the burgeoning counterculture.
The song also gave rise to the 1969 film adaptation directed by Arthur Penn, with Guthrie and Brock appearing as themselves. Reflecting on the experience, she often mentioned how the Hollywood interpretation simplified the complex lifestyles and personalities involved, which included layers of art, activism, and community building.
Alice’s passing adds singular poignance to the upcoming Thanksgiving celebrations, the first without her physical presence. She leaves behind memories and laughter intertwined with the values her life embodied. Marginalized as she felt by mainstream portrayals, she nonetheless found joy and humor right until the end, according to her friend Viki Merrick, who shared her final days were filled with laughter and wit.
“Alice remained poetic, hilariously funny, and full of puns. That’s the way Alice has always been,” recalled Merrick after her death. Her wisdom came not only from her craft but also from the rich relationships she cultivated—whether they were artists, musicians, or misfits who gathered around her tables—becoming part of the oral goodness of the Berkshires.
Thanks to the enduring resonance of Guthrie’s song and the warmth of Alice’s legacy, she will live on every time someone gathers to share stories and give thanks, as friends do around tables globally. Let’s hope this Thanksgiving, as we hear those familiar chords and melodic lines, we don’t just hear Alice’s Restaurant; we feel Alice’s essence—a spirit of rebellion, community, humor, and love for those who matter most.
link
